Understanding Eminent Domain: Your Rights, the Process, and Legal Implications

Have you ever wondered what happens when the government wants your land for a new highway or public project? This process, known as eminent domain, affects thousands of property owners each year. Whether you're a homeowner, real estate investor, or simply curious about property rights, understanding eminent domain is essential in today's real estate landscape.

Understanding eminent domain

What does eminent domain mean?

Eminent domain is the government's power to take private property for public use while providing fair compensation to the property owner. This concept affects real estate transactions across the country and has been the subject of numerous legal battles.

"Eminent domain is when the government takes the private property of a citizen for public use," explains Bill Thrush, Managing Partner of Friedman, Framme & Thrush and LegalShield provider lawyer. "The private property owner is entitled to fair compensation for the property. The details of how it works depend upon which government (federal, state or local) is taking land and that jurisdiction's specific eminent domain laws."

How does eminent domain work?

The eminent domain process typically follows these general steps:

1. Identification - The government identifies property needed for public use.
2. Notification - Property owners receive formal notice of the government's intent.
3. Valuation - Appraisers determine the "fair market value" of the property.
4. Negotiation - The government attempts to purchase the property voluntarily.
5. Condemnation - If negotiations fail, formal legal proceedings begin.
6. Compensation - Property owners receive payment for their taken property.

This process can vary significantly depending on local laws and the specific circumstances of each case. If you want to know how eminent domain works in your state and situation, you need to contact a lawyer who is well-versed in dealing with these types of issues.

Legal basis for eminent domain

Fifth Amendment Eminent Domain Clause

The foundation of eminent domain authority comes directly from the U.S. Constitution.

"The concept of eminent domain is rooted in the 5th Amendment to the US Constitution," notes Thrush, "which states, '...nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.'"

This constitutional protection ensures that while the government has the power to take property, it must still follow these critical rules:

1. Use the property for public use.
2. Provide just compensation to the property owner.

Key legal precedents

Over time, the Supreme Court and lower courts have shaped and defined the boundaries of eminent domain through various landmark decisions. These precedents help determine what constitutes "public use" and "just compensation" in different contexts.

When and why the government uses eminent domain

Common uses of eminent domain

The government typically exercises eminent domain for projects deemed beneficial to the public. These are a few situations wherein the government may need to purchase private property:

• Transportation infrastructure (highways, bridges, airports)
• Utilities (water lines, electrical grids, gas pipelines)
• Public facilities (schools, hospitals, government buildings)
• Urban renewal projects (addressing blight or economic development)
• Environmental conservation (parks, wetlands preservation)

Eminent domain in real estate

In the real estate context, eminent domain becomes particularly complex.

Thrush explains, "The government can take private property that is for public use. But the devil is in the details, insofar as what each jurisdiction defines as a public use. For example, in my home state of Maryland, the courts define a public use very broadly. It is not just for a use by the public at large, but also for a use that provides a public benefit."

He continues, "Once the public use has been determined, then there must be a determination of what is 'just compensation' for the property. Again, this can vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, but many use the fair market value as the yardstick of just compensation. In Maryland, fair market value is defined as the price that a willing seller, who is not obligated to sell, would accept, and a willing buyer, who is not obligated to buy, would pay for the property, considering its highest and best use."

Eminent domain process & property owner rights

Government seizing land: Step-by-step breakdown

When facing an eminent domain claim, property owners should understand the typical progression:

1. Initial Contact - Government representatives approach with information about the project.
2. Property Assessment - Officials evaluate the property's value.
3. Purchase Offer - The government representative presents an initial compensation offer.
4. Negotiation Period - Property owners can contest the offer with their own valuation.
5. Legal Filing - If agreement isn't reached, the government files a condemnation lawsuit.
6. Court Proceedings - Both sides present evidence regarding value and necessity.
7. Settlement or Judgment - Either the parties agree on compensation, or a judge/jury decides.
8. Property Transfer - Ownership transfers to the government upon payment.

It’s best to quickly seek help from a lawyer if a government official comes to you with an offer for your private property. Whether you want to sell or you want to fight for your property, you need to take legal assistance with you into this complex process.

What property is exempt from eminent domain?  

Not all property can be seized through eminent domain. Thrush points out:

"The answer to this question could be jurisdictionally specific as well. In Maryland, there are several types of properties that are exempted or otherwise restricted in eminent domain. Those include farming or other agricultural properties with scenic easements or land preservation easements, natural resources such as rivers, cemeteries, some infrastructural properties such as sewage or water systems, or property already owned by a government."

These exemptions vary by state and local regulations, so understanding your specific location's rules is essential.

Can property owners refuse eminent domain claims?

Many property owners wonder if they can simply decline an eminent domain claim. The answer is more nuanced than a simple yes or no.

"A property owner cannot refuse eminent domain as much as challenge it," Thrush clarifies. "Specifically, the owner can force the government to prove that the taking of private property meets the constitutional and statutory requirements for eminent domain (i.e., public use, just compensation, not restricted property)."

This means property owners have the right to take these steps:

• Question the public purpose of the taking.
• Challenge the necessity of using that specific property.
• Contest the compensation amount offered.
• Ensure proper procedures were followed.

Controversies & notable cases

Has anyone won an eminent domain case?

While challenging the government's right to take property is difficult, property owners have succeeded in various ways:

• Receiving substantially higher compensation than initially offered
• Proving the taking doesn't satisfy genuine public use requirements
• Demonstrating procedural errors in the eminent domain process
• Negotiating better terms or partial takings instead of complete seizures

Significant legal cases of eminent domain

When asked about significant legal cases in eminent domain, Thrush noted, "That would really depend on the jurisdiction involved." Indeed, while some Supreme Court cases have shaped the national understanding of eminent domain, state and local cases often have the most direct impact on property owners in specific regions.

Understanding your rights

If you're facing an eminent domain claim, knowing your legal options is crucial for protecting your interests.

"If a reader is facing this issue, they should know that legal counsel is priceless in terms of helping to analyze and navigate the process of eminent domain from challenge to completion," advises Thrush. "The process of eminent domain can be complicated, especially if the private owner wishes to challenge the taking of property. Without someone who has legal experience in that arena, navigating that process will be difficult, stressful, and long, like wandering through a dense forest in the dark with no shoes on your feet."

When confronted with eminent domain, consider these steps:

1. Get informed about your state's specific eminent domain laws.
2. Document everything related to your property and the government's claims.
3. Obtain an independent appraisal to determine fair market value.
4. Consult with an attorney who has experience in eminent domain.
5. Explore negotiation options before proceeding to litigation.
6. Know the deadline for challenging the government's actions.

Understanding eminent domain—from its constitutional foundations to the practical process—empowers property owners to protect their rights while navigating this complex legal terrain.

Remember: While the government has significant power through eminent domain, property owners have rights too. Knowing how to effectively assert these rights can make all the difference in securing fair treatment and just compensation.

When you sign up for a LegalShield Membership, you gain access to a LegalShield provider law firm that can assist you in this area. Our provider lawyers can schedule consultations, answer questions on an unlimited number of personal legal matters, review documents, help with letters and phone calls, and perform other essential covered legal services. You don’t have to find answers or face eminent domain cases on your own.

Find out how LegalShield can get you the help that you deserve today.

__________________________________________________________________________________

Written by Elyse Dillard, Content Specialist at LegalShield. Elyse creates educational resources about legal and identity theft protection services. She works to make complex legal concepts more accessible to readers and has contributed to numerous articles on the LegalShield blog.

Bill Thrush is a shareholder and the Managing Partner of Friedman, Framme & Thrush. Bill is an experienced trial attorney and has tried cases at all levels of court throughout the state of Maryland, as well as the District of Columbia and the Commonwealth of Virginia.

Pre-Paid Legal Services, Inc. (“PPLSI”) is not a law firm. PPLSI provides access to legal services offered by a network of provider law firms to PPLSI members through membership-based participation. Neither PPLSI nor its officers, employees or sales associates directly or indirectly provide legal services, representation, or advice. The information made available in this blog is meant to provide general information and is not intended to provide legal advice, render an opinion, or provide a recommendation as to a specific matter. The blog post is not a substitute for competent legal counsel from a licensed professional lawyer in the state or province where your legal issues exist, and you should seek legal counsel for your specific legal matter. Information contained in the blog may be provided by authors who could be a third-party paid contributor. All information by authors is accepted in good faith, however, PPLSI makes no representation or warranty of any kind, express or implied, regarding the accuracy, adequacy, validity, reliability, availability, or completeness of such information.

‍